Puppy Food: Salmon & Haddock vs Turkey & Rice
By MyPetSays | Published: 2026-10-19
Category: Comparisons
Compare grain free salmon and haddock puppy food with natural turkey and rice recipe. Find out which option suits your pup's needs and digestion.
Quick answer
For puppies with grain sensitivities or food intolerances, the grain free salmon and haddock recipe is the better choice. If your pup has a sensitive stomach but tolerates grains well, the natural turkey and rice formula offers easily digestible protein and carbohydrates.
Protein sources and digestibility
Salmon is a highly digestible protein source, making it ideal for puppies that need gentle nutrition. Turkey is a lean protein rich in essential amino acids, which supports muscle development without being heavy on the stomach.
Both recipes use single, novel protein sources, which can help identify or avoid food sensitivities. However, the grain free option removes grains entirely, which may be unnecessary for puppies that digest grains without issues.
Carbohydrates and fiber
The salmon and haddock recipe uses sweet potato as a carbohydrate source, which provides fiber and vitamins. The turkey and rice recipe uses rice, an easily digestible carbohydrate that is gentle on sensitive tummies.
Sweet potato offers more fiber and a lower glycemic index, while rice is simpler to digest. If your puppy has a very sensitive stomach, rice may be the safer bet. For a more nutrient-dense carbohydrate, sweet potato is a solid choice.
How to choose between salmon & haddock and turkey & rice
- Grain sensitivity or intolerance: Choose the grain free salmon and haddock recipe. It avoids grains entirely while still providing balanced nutrition for growth.
- Sensitive stomach that tolerates grains: The natural turkey and rice formula is designed for puppies with sensitive digestion. Rice is a simple carbohydrate that is easy on the stomach.
- Protein preference and variety: If your puppy has eaten chicken or beef before and reacted poorly, salmon or turkey may be novel proteins worth trying. Both recipes offer single protein sources. Introduce any new food gradually over 7-10 days to monitor tolerance.
Product facts at a glance
- Grain Free Puppy Food - Salmon & Haddock with Sweet Potato & Asparagus: Grain Free Puppy Food - Salmon & Haddock with Sweet Potato & Asparagus is a grain-free recipe perfect for puppies with food sensitivities or grain intolerance. It provides all essential nutrients for growth while avoiding grains that can trigger allergic reactions or digestive upset.
Grain Free Puppy Food - Salmon & Haddock with Sweet Potato & Asparagus - Naturals Puppy Food - Turkey & Rice: Naturals Puppy Food - Turkey & Rice is made with turkey, a lean protein source rich in essential amino acids, and rice, an easily digestible carbohydrate. This combination supports overall health and is gentle on puppies with sensitive tummies that can tolerate grains.
Naturals Puppy Food - Turkey & Rice
Which puppy food fits your pup?
Best for
- Puppies with grain allergies or intolerances – choose the grain free salmon and haddock recipe
- Puppies with sensitive stomachs that can digest grains – choose the natural turkey and rice formula
Not for
- Puppies that need a grain-inclusive diet for specific health reasons – the grain free option may not suit them
- Puppies with a known intolerance to fish or poultry – both recipes use animal proteins
